Skip to content

Christmas gifts: see order-by dates →

Giddy PetsGiddy Pets

Cat food for puppies: why it's the wrong choice

If a puppy has helped themselves to the cat's bowl, a single mouthful is not something to worry about, but cat food is not a food to choose for a puppy on any regular basis. Cats and dogs have genuinely different nutritional needs, and cat food is formulated around a cat's, not a growing puppy's.

Why cat food doesn't fit a puppy's needs

Cats are obligate carnivores with a much higher protein and fat requirement than dogs, and cat food is built around that — it tends to be far more calorie-dense and higher in fat than a puppy needs, without the specific balance of nutrients a growing dog's bones and joints depend on. Fed regularly, that mismatch shows up as excess weight gain and an unbalanced diet during exactly the period when a puppy's growth needs the most careful support.

Puppy food, by contrast, is formulated around a growing dog's needs specifically — a calcium and phosphorus balance suited to developing bones, and an energy density matched to how much a puppy that size should realistically be eating. The two are not interchangeable just because both are technically 'pet food'.

You'll find our dry dog food in the shop.

What actually happens if a puppy eats cat food occasionally

An odd mouthful from a shared household, picked up in passing, is not something to lose sleep over — it is not toxic and one incident will not cause lasting harm. Watch for a looser stool or an upset stomach over the following day, which is more likely than anything more serious, and mention it to a vet if it doesn't settle or your puppy seems genuinely unwell.

The concern is with a puppy eating cat food as a habit rather than an accident. If access is a recurring problem — a puppy who can reach the cat's bowl every day — that's worth solving properly, whether that means feeding the cat somewhere the puppy can't reach or using a feeding station designed to keep the two separate.

Households with both a cat and a puppy often find the simplest fix is a physical barrier rather than constant supervision — a cat flap into a puppy-free room, a raised feeding shelf a cat can reach but a puppy can't, or a feeding time schedule that keeps the two apart while bowls are down. Whatever the setup, the goal is the same: each animal eating its own food, formulated for its own needs, without daily negotiation over whose bowl is whose.

What we stock

Everything below is in stock with us, priced with delivery worked out, and packed and posted by hand in the UK.

Pedigree Tasty Minis Puppy Treats Chewy Cubes with Chicken

Pedigree Tasty Minis Puppy Treats Chewy Cubes with Chicken

£2.25

Forthglade Complete Puppy Chicken with Liver Grain Free — 18 x 395g Trays

Forthglade Complete Puppy Chicken with Liver Grain Free — 18 x 395g Trays

£35.89

Bakers Puppy Superfoods Chicken with Vegetables

Bakers Puppy Superfoods Chicken with Vegetables

£39.15

Burgess Supadog Puppy Chicken

Burgess Supadog Puppy Chicken

£35.35

Harringtons Puppy Turkey & Rice

Harringtons Puppy Turkey & Rice

£6.49

James Wellbeloved Grain Free Puppy/Junior Dry Dog Food Turkey & Veg

James Wellbeloved Grain Free Puppy/Junior Dry Dog Food Turkey & Veg

£12.75

Wagg Puppy Treats

Wagg Puppy Treats

£1.49

Burns Puppy Junior Original Chicken Rice

Burns Puppy Junior Original Chicken Rice

From£14.99

Lily's Kitchen Puppy Chicken Recipe — 6 x 400g Tins

Lily's Kitchen Puppy Chicken Recipe — 6 x 400g Tins

£22.79

Pooch & Mutt Puppy Bite Size Beef Jerky

Pooch & Mutt Puppy Bite Size Beef Jerky

£3.99

Whimzees Puppy

Whimzees Puppy

£7.99

Burns Grain Free Puppy Duck Potato

Burns Grain Free Puppy Duck Potato

From£16.49

Browse all of Dogs →

Common questions

Is cat food toxic to puppies?
No, it isn't toxic. The issue is that it's nutritionally unbalanced for a growing puppy rather than dangerous in the way some human foods are, so an occasional mouthful is not an emergency, but it shouldn't become a regular part of the diet.
What should I feed a growing puppy instead?
A complete puppy food formulated for their expected adult size — small, medium or large breed — is the right foundation, fed according to the guide on the bag and adjusted for body condition as they grow. A vet can help if you're unsure which is the right fit.
How do I stop my puppy eating the cat's food?
Feeding the cat somewhere the puppy genuinely can't reach — raised up, behind a barrier, or in a separate room — is usually the most reliable fix, since puppies are persistent and a bowl left on the floor is rarely safe from a curious dog for long.
Can kittens eat puppy food instead?
No, for the same reason in reverse — puppy food doesn't meet a kitten's higher protein and fat needs. Each species needs food formulated specifically for it, and a kitten-specific food is the right choice for a growing kitten.

Related

Written by Matt Garnett, who runs Giddy Pets and is a lifelong pet owner — not a vet. This is general information, not veterinary advice, and it cannot replace an examination by the vet who knows your animal. How we write these guides.