A training treat lives or dies on how many times you can hand one over in a session before a dog loses interest in working for the next one, which is really a question of size and repeatability rather than anything more complicated.

Lily's Kitchen build these training treats on organic light rye flour and rolled oats, with organic apple puree at 10%, organic cheese at 6%, dried yeasts, organic sunflower oil, organic flaxseed at 1% and organic rosehips at 1%. The analytical constituents are Crude Protein 10.5%, Crude Fat 8% and Crude Ash 2%. Lily's Kitchen's own guidance is up to five treats a day for adult dogs from four months, and to reseal the pack tightly and use it within 28 days of opening, in an 80g size.

• Organic apple puree 10%, organic cheese 6%
• Organic flaxseed 1%, organic rosehips 1%
• Crude Protein 10.5%, Crude Fat 8%, Crude Ash 2%
• Up to 5 treats a day, for adult dogs from 4 months
• Use within 28 days of opening
• 80g pack

On the 28-day window. Lily's Kitchen's own instruction is to use the pack within 28 days once it is opened, which is worth checking against how often you actually train — a pack that sits open for longer than that is past what the manufacturer has tested for freshness.

Who it's for: owners doing regular training sessions who want a small, organic biscuit with named ingredients like cheese and flaxseed, rather than an unspecified "meat meal" treat.