Dog treats for picky eaters
A genuinely picky dog usually responds better to a treat with a stronger smell and a texture they actually enjoy than to sheer variety for its own sake. Freeze-dried or dehydrated single-ingredient meat treats tend to be the most reliably appealing option, since the aroma is more concentrated than in a baked biscuit-style treat.
Why smell matters more than most owners expect
Dogs rely heavily on smell when deciding whether something is worth eating, far more than taste in the way humans experience it. A treat with a strong, meaty aroma — freeze-dried liver, dehydrated fish, or similar single-ingredient options — tends to get a much stronger reaction from a picky dog than a milder-smelling baked biscuit, even if the biscuit is nutritionally similar.
This is also why breaking a treat into smaller pieces can help: it releases more aroma per piece given, which for some picky dogs makes a real difference to how enthusiastically they respond, independent of the actual quantity offered.
Texture and format make a difference too
Some dogs that turn their nose up at hard biscuits will happily take a soft, chewy treat, and vice versa — there's real individual variation here that's worth testing rather than assuming. Older dogs in particular sometimes become pickier about hard treats simply because they're less comfortable to chew, which is worth bearing in mind if a previously enthusiastic dog has recently become fussier.
Rotating a small number of different textures — a freeze-dried option, a soft chew, an occasional natural chew — rather than sticking to one type can also help maintain interest for a dog who seems to get bored of the same treat over time.
When pickiness is worth a vet check
Occasional fussiness with treats specifically, while a dog eats normal meals fine, usually just reflects preference. A dog that's suddenly gone off food generally, treats included, or has lost their appetite alongside other changes like lethargy or weight loss, is a different situation and worth a vet visit rather than trying yet another treat.
It's worth distinguishing genuine appetite loss from simple fussiness before assuming a new treat will solve the problem — the two look similar from the outside but call for very different responses, and treating a health issue as a fussy phase can mean it goes unnoticed for longer than it should.
What we stock
Everything below is in stock with us, priced with delivery worked out, and packed and posted by hand in the UK.
Calm the Eff Down Treats Chicken Flavour 90 Tablets
Chicken-flavoured calming tablets from Pets Calm Down, made in the UK, ninety to a pack and given as a treat for dogs who find fireworks, travel or being alone difficult.
£22.99
Stop Bloody Scratching Treats Chicken Flavour 90 Tablets
Chicken-flavoured tablets from Pets Calm Down, made in the UK, ninety to a pack, given daily as a treat to support skin and coat condition in itchy dogs.
£22.99
Forthglade Grain Free Soft Bites Fresh Breath Treats 8pk
Chicken soft dog treats with parsley and peppermint oil for fresh breath
£2.45
James Wellbeloved Adult Dry Cat Food Turkey
A single-source turkey dry food for adult cats, without the grain-free or joint-support extras
From£21.79
Catit Nibbly Jerky Chicken & Fish Treats
Soft chicken and fish jerky treats for cats, two named meats high on the list, grain free
£1.89
Whiskas 1+ Lamb Adult Dry Cat Food
Complete lamb dry food for adult cats in a practical 1.9KG bag
£12.39
Whiskas 1 Tuna Adult Dry Cat Food
Complete tuna dry food for adult cats, offered in several bag sizes
From£3.19
Whiskas Kitten Chicken Dry Cat Food
Complete chicken dry food for kittens, available in several bag sizes
From£3.19
Whiskas 7+ Senior Cat Complete Dry with Chicken
Complete chicken dry food for senior cats aged 7+ in a 1.9KG bag
£12.39
Catit Creamy Tuna Treats 4 Pk
Lickable 26% tuna purée tubes for cats, 4 x 10g, up to 3 a day in place of main meal
£1.89
Pedigree Dentastix Light Dog
Pedigree DentaStix Light dental chews across small, medium and large sizes
From£2.35
Common questions
- Why does my dog ignore some treats but love others?
- Smell plays a much bigger role for dogs than it does for people, so treats with a stronger, more concentrated aroma — freeze-dried or dehydrated meat, for example — often get a far stronger reaction than a milder-smelling baked treat, even one that's nutritionally similar.
- Are freeze-dried treats better for picky dogs?
- They're often more effective simply because the aroma is more concentrated than in a baked biscuit, which tends to appeal more strongly to a dog relying on smell. It's worth trying if your dog has been unenthusiastic about more processed treats.
- My older dog has suddenly become picky about treats — why?
- It's sometimes down to hard treats becoming less comfortable to chew as a dog ages, which can make them seem fussier without anything else being wrong. If the change is sudden or accompanied by other signs, though, it's worth having your vet check for a dental or health cause.
- When should I worry about a picky eater rather than just try new treats?
- If your dog is only fussy about treats specifically and still eats normal meals well, it's usually just preference. If they've gone off food generally, or fussiness comes with other changes like lethargy or weight loss, that's worth a vet visit rather than continuing to try different treats.
Related
Written by Matt Garnett, who runs Giddy Pets and is a lifelong pet owner — not a vet. This is general information, not veterinary advice, and it cannot replace an examination by the vet who knows your animal. How we write these guides.