Felix as Good as It Looks Ocean Feasts 12pk Pm£4.75

Cats have a reputation for fussiness that is mostly slander. What actually happens is that a cat settles early on what food is supposed to look and smell like, and then spends years politely declining anything that does not match. That is the argument for an assortment over a case of one recipe, and the reason nobody should feel guilty about the four open boxes in the cupboard.

These are tender pieces in jelly, twelve pouches of 85g. The cod recipe reads meat and animal derivatives (12%), vegetable protein extracts, fish and fish derivatives (cod 4%), minerals and various sugars, with the chunks themselves 40% meat and animal derivatives; the salmon recipe is built the same way with salmon at 4%. Analytical constituents are protein 11%, fat content 2.3%, crude ash 2.5%, crude fibre 0.05%, moisture 82% and omega 6 fatty acids 0.40%. The feeding guide is three to four pouches a day for an average adult cat of 4kg, across at least two meals, served at room temperature.

• Twelve 85g pouches, tender pieces in jelly
• The named fish is declared at 4% in each recipe
• Meat and animal derivatives 12%; the chunks are 40% meat and animal derivatives
• Protein 11%, fat content 2.3%, crude ash 2.5%, crude fibre 0.05%
• Moisture 82%, omega 6 fatty acids 0.40%
• Guide of three to four pouches a day for an average adult cat of 4kg

Ocean Feasts is 4% ocean. Cod is declared at 4% in the cod recipe and salmon at 4% in the salmon one. The bigger meat figure on the label - 12%, and 40% of the chunks - is "meat and animal derivatives", a legal category that names no species and is not fish. None of that is unusual at this price and none of it is hidden, but the picture on the front and the ingredient panel on the back are telling two different stories and it is worth knowing which one to read. Two further gaps: the data supplied to us does not state whether this is a complete or a complementary food, though the feeding guide reads as a full daily ration, and various sugars appear in every recipe with no figure attached.

Who it's for: owners of adult cats who feed pouches, want an assortment rather than a case of one thing, and have a cat that has already made its feelings clear about jelly versus gravy.